By Joseph Trifilo, The Trifilo Team | HUNT Real Estate ERA

Here's something we see all the time in Williamsville, Amherst and Clarence: a homeowner decides it's time to sell, picks up the phone and calls one agent. Usually it's someone a neighbor recommended or someone they've worked with before.

That instinct is common nationwide. A 2026 Zillow survey found that most sellers who hired an agent contacted only one before signing. So if you're only going to make one call, it pays to make it a good one. Here's how to do that.

Two-story white home with a wraparound porch surrounded by fall foliage in Western New York

Why Is the First Agent You Call So Important?

Because for most sellers, that first call becomes the hire. Few homeowners shop around the way they would for a contractor or a car. The agent you call first is very likely the person who will price your home, market it, negotiate your offers and guide you to closing.

That's a lot riding on one conversation. A little preparation helps you walk in confident.

Where Do Western New York Sellers Find an Agent They Trust?

Buffalo-Niagara is a relationship-driven market. In our experience, most sellers find their agent through:

  • A recommendation from family, friends, coworkers or neighbors

  • A past transaction, such as the agent who helped them buy their current home

  • Local involvement, like school, church, youth sports or community events

  • Online research, including reviews, recent sales and helpful content like this blog

Whichever way you find an agent, look for someone who actually knows your streets, your school district and how homes like yours have been selling lately.

Is Trust or Cost More Important When Hiring a Listing Agent?

For most sellers, trust comes first. In Zillow's 2026 research, far more sellers rated trustworthiness as highly important than said the same about a lower commission.

That lines up with what we hear from clients. Selling a home is personal and financial at the same time. You want someone who tells you the truth about price, keeps you informed and protects your interests through every step.

Real estate commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable between you and your brokerage.

Selling and Buying at the Same Time? One Agent Can Help

Many local moves involve two transactions, like selling a starter home in Cheektowaga to buy in East Amherst, or downsizing from Clarence to a patio home in Williamsville. Working with one agent on both sides can make it easier to:

  • Line up closing dates so you're not paying for two homes longer than needed

  • Plan around sale and purchase contingencies

  • Keep one point of contact for paperwork, inspections and timelines

Can AI or Online Tools Tell Me What My Home Is Worth?

They can give you a ballpark. Plenty of homeowners now use AI tools and online estimates to learn the basics of selling and get a feel for the market, and that's a smart place to start.

What those tools can't see is what makes your home yours: the finished basement, the new roof, the quiet cul-de-sac, or how quickly similar homes nearby have gone under contract. A local comparative market analysis fills in those gaps.

Homeowners reviewing plans on a laptop in their kitchen before selling their home

5 Questions to Ask on Your First Call

  1. How would you price my home? Ask to see recent nearby sales.

  2. How will you market it? Ask about photography, online exposure and the launch plan.

  3. How often will we talk? Set expectations for updates early.

  4. Can you help with my next home too? Make sure they can coordinate both moves.

  5. What are your fees, and what's included? Get everything in writing.

Ready to Talk About Selling?

If you're thinking about a move anywhere in Western New York, The Trifilo Team is glad to be your first call. No pressure and no obligation. Just an honest conversation about your goals, your timeline and what today's market looks like for a home like yours.

Contact The Trifilo Team at HUNT Real Estate ERA to get started.
(716) 553-3939

Frequently Asked Questions

How many agents should I interview before selling?
There's no required number. Many sellers talk to just one they already trust. If you meet with more than one, compare their pricing approach, marketing plan and communication style.

Should I use the same agent to buy and sell?
You don't have to, but it often makes timing and coordination simpler.

How accurate are online home value estimates?
They're a useful starting point. For a more accurate number, ask a local agent for a comparative market analysis.

Source: Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report, 2026. National survey data may not reflect local market conditions. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

The Trifilo Sales Team is affiliated with HUNT Real Estate ERA. Each office is independently owned and operated. Equal Housing Opportunity.